<<Boards Main>>
Tosa Town Square
»
Schools, Education
»
Schools, Education
»
RI City Fires Teachers: Union Howls
|
|
Rank: Newbie Groups: Member
Joined: 2/22/2010 Posts: 3
|
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/25/education/25central.htmlThis is what is needed in MPS and maybe in some Tosa schools, this is very Reaganesque!
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
So you think Obama is Reaganesque. Interesting. Meanwhile, the fact that a union is protesting the firing of the people it represents is hardly news. Here's an article from the Providence Journal, which covers Central Falls, on the incident. An excerpt talking about the national picture is highlighted. Perhaps the unions' willingness to collaborate in other districts is part of the reason we're not hearing more stories like this one. http://www.projo.com/news/content/central_falls_trustees_vote_02-24-10_EOHI83C_v59.3c21342.html "While federal law has long allowed the overhaul of chronically failing schools, such extreme makeovers are likely to become more common because of more money from Washington, a growing consensus on education reform, and newfound willingness on the part of teacher unions to collaborate, experts say." The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize. Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 6/11/2007 Posts: 2,198
|
I was glad to read the linked article which shed a lot more light on the situation than anything I’d seen previously. Although I initially thought it was a stupid, non-productive, knee-jerk reaction on the part of the board, the pretty good article seems to place a lot of the onus on the teachers’ union not using a little common sense in their negotiations. I would have thought they’d at least be more protective of their jobs.
But, I still think this is show boating on the part of everyone from Duncan on down. Are we supposed to believe the crummiest teachers always end up with the crummiest scores from their students on standardized tests? I suspect none of the sanctioned schools are located in a suburb with demographics similar to, say, Wauwatosa – what a coincidence that we always find the bad teachers in heavily minority schools in high poverty areas. We must make high scores here because of the really good teachers we have, right?
It’s also no surprise to me to discover that Rhode Island is one of the states that has a school choice voucher system. It’s pretty clear that a school like the one in question has been sucked dry of any student who has parents who want to get them out of a pool of troublemakers who nobody gives a darn about except maybe a classroom teacher.
So the solution is to fire the staff? Good luck on the big turnaround when they fill the vacancies with superteachers to fill the vacuum.
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde (anticipating, well over 100 years ago, anonymous Internet discussions)
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
izzie wrote:I was glad to read the linked article which shed a lot more light on the situation than anything I’d seen previously. Although I initially thought it was a stupid, non-productive, knee-jerk reaction on the part of the board, the pretty good article seems to place a lot of the onus on the teachers’ union not using a little common sense in their negotiations. I would have thought they’d at least be more protective of their jobs.
But, I still think this is show boating on the part of everyone from Duncan on down. Are we supposed to believe the crummiest teachers always end up with the crummiest scores from their students on standardized tests? I suspect none of the sanctioned schools are located in a suburb with demographics similar to, say, Wauwatosa – what a coincidence that we always find the bad teachers in heavily minority schools in high poverty areas. We must make high scores here because of the really good teachers we have, right?
It’s also no surprise to me to discover that Rhode Island is one of the states that has a school choice voucher system. It’s pretty clear that a school like the one in question has been sucked dry of any student who has parents who want to get them out of a pool of troublemakers who nobody gives a darn about except maybe a classroom teacher.
So the solution is to fire the staff? Good luck on the big turnaround when they fill the vacancies with superteachers to fill the vacuum. They can hire teachers back, but no more than 50% so they'll have to fill half the vacancies with new hires. I lived in Providence in the '60s when it was the armpit of America. There have been improvements in the ambiance since then, but I'm guessing that places like Central Falls are still kind of depressed. It's probably an old mill town, just like every place else in Rhode Island. This just just isn't the kind of place that's going to attract lots of bright young things eager to bring new ideas and approaches to educating its children. I'm predicting this will turn out to be a mistake, but we'll see. The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize. Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 10/28/2008 Posts: 426 Location: The underworld of Wauwatosa
|
Nancy wrote:izzie wrote:I was glad to read the linked article which shed a lot more light on the situation than anything I’d seen previously. Although I initially thought it was a stupid, non-productive, knee-jerk reaction on the part of the board, the pretty good article seems to place a lot of the onus on the teachers’ union not using a little common sense in their negotiations. I would have thought they’d at least be more protective of their jobs.
But, I still think this is show boating on the part of everyone from Duncan on down. Are we supposed to believe the crummiest teachers always end up with the crummiest scores from their students on standardized tests? I suspect none of the sanctioned schools are located in a suburb with demographics similar to, say, Wauwatosa – what a coincidence that we always find the bad teachers in heavily minority schools in high poverty areas. We must make high scores here because of the really good teachers we have, right?
It’s also no surprise to me to discover that Rhode Island is one of the states that has a school choice voucher system. It’s pretty clear that a school like the one in question has been sucked dry of any student who has parents who want to get them out of a pool of troublemakers who nobody gives a darn about except maybe a classroom teacher.
So the solution is to fire the staff? Good luck on the big turnaround when they fill the vacancies with superteachers to fill the vacuum. They can hire teachers back, but no more than 50% so they'll have to fill half the vacancies with new hires. I lived in Providence in the '60s when it was the armpit of America. There have been improvements in the ambiance since then, but I'm guessing that places like Central Falls are still kind of depressed. It's probably an old mill town, just like every place else in Rhode Island. This just just isn't the kind of place that's going to attract lots of bright young things eager to bring new ideas and approaches to educating its children. I'm predicting this will turn out to be a mistake, but we'll see. The Troll is not surprised our well- traveled Nancy has first hand experience with Rhode Island. She is our resident Rhode(s) scholar  Just amazing how she has been everywhere, experienced everything, yet still contributes to our daily lives in such plentitude. The Troll says Warwick, R.I. is not a run down mill town. In fact, Rhode Island is quite lovely.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 3/17/2008 Posts: 726 Location: tosa
|
The Troll wrote:The Troll is not surprised our well- traveled Nancy has first hand experience with Rhode Island. She is our resident Rhode(s) scholar  Just amazing how she has been everywhere, experienced everything, yet still contributes to our daily lives in such plentitude. The Troll says Warwick, R.I. is not a run down mill town. In fact, Rhode Island is quite lovely. The 60's were a long time ago. Now... if she starts saying that she helped build the great wall of China carrying bricks uphill (both ways)... then I'll agree. That's another odd thing I noticed about this area... nobody leaves. I once attended a large (200+) meeting at Northwestern Mutual. One of the ice breakers was that you needed to answer one of three questions before you could ask the speaker a question. About 15 people were asked "What is your favorite city to visit?" and none of them could even answer the question. They couldn't even just say "Boston" or "Chicago" just to make conversation... they typically answered "I dunno, I uh... never really have gone anywhere." Now... it could just be that they were Information Technology people and were more recluse... but I found the whole experience interesting. Sorry for the digression... but your comment, troll, reminded me of those people.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 6/11/2007 Posts: 2,198
|
rubber wrote:About 15 people were asked "What is your favorite city to visit?" and none of them could even answer the question. They couldn't even just say "Boston" or "Chicago" just to make conversation... they typically answered "I dunno, I uh... never really have gone anywhere." Maybe they were all relatives of Sarah Palin. It seems oddly reminiscent of the campaign . . .
Man is least himself when he talks in his own person. Give him a mask, and he will tell you the truth. -Oscar Wilde (anticipating, well over 100 years ago, anonymous Internet discussions)
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 9/15/2007 Posts: 1,358 Location: wauwatosa a long time ago
|
rubber wrote:The Troll wrote:The Troll is not surprised our well- traveled Nancy has first hand experience with Rhode Island. She is our resident Rhode(s) scholar  Just amazing how she has been everywhere, experienced everything, yet still contributes to our daily lives in such plentitude. The Troll says Warwick, R.I. is not a run down mill town. In fact, Rhode Island is quite lovely. The 60's were a long time ago. Now... if she starts saying that she helped build the great wall of China carrying bricks uphill (both ways)... then I'll agree. That's another odd thing I noticed about this area... nobody leaves. I once attended a large (200+) meeting at Northwestern Mutual. One of the ice breakers was that you needed to answer one of three questions before you could ask the speaker a question. About 15 people were asked "What is your favorite city to visit?" and none of them could even answer the question. They couldn't even just say "Boston" or "Chicago" just to make conversation... they typically answered "I dunno, I uh... never really have gone anywhere." Now... it could just be that they were Information Technology people and were more recluse... but I found the whole experience interesting. Sorry for the digression... but your comment, troll, reminded me of those people. When you find paradise there is very little reason to leave.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
The Troll wrote:Nancy wrote:izzie wrote:I was glad to read the linked article which shed a lot more light on the situation than anything I’d seen previously. Although I initially thought it was a stupid, non-productive, knee-jerk reaction on the part of the board, the pretty good article seems to place a lot of the onus on the teachers’ union not using a little common sense in their negotiations. I would have thought they’d at least be more protective of their jobs.
But, I still think this is show boating on the part of everyone from Duncan on down. Are we supposed to believe the crummiest teachers always end up with the crummiest scores from their students on standardized tests? I suspect none of the sanctioned schools are located in a suburb with demographics similar to, say, Wauwatosa – what a coincidence that we always find the bad teachers in heavily minority schools in high poverty areas. We must make high scores here because of the really good teachers we have, right?
It’s also no surprise to me to discover that Rhode Island is one of the states that has a school choice voucher system. It’s pretty clear that a school like the one in question has been sucked dry of any student who has parents who want to get them out of a pool of troublemakers who nobody gives a darn about except maybe a classroom teacher.
So the solution is to fire the staff? Good luck on the big turnaround when they fill the vacancies with superteachers to fill the vacuum. They can hire teachers back, but no more than 50% so they'll have to fill half the vacancies with new hires. I lived in Providence in the '60s when it was the armpit of America. There have been improvements in the ambiance since then, but I'm guessing that places like Central Falls are still kind of depressed. It's probably an old mill town, just like every place else in Rhode Island. This just just isn't the kind of place that's going to attract lots of bright young things eager to bring new ideas and approaches to educating its children. I'm predicting this will turn out to be a mistake, but we'll see. The Troll is not surprised our well- traveled Nancy has first hand experience with Rhode Island. She is our resident Rhode(s) scholar  Just amazing how she has been everywhere, experienced everything, yet still contributes to our daily lives in such plentitude. The Troll says Warwick, R.I. is not a run down mill town. In fact, Rhode Island is quite lovely. As I said, I lived there forty years ago. That's where I went to art school. I'm aware that it's nicer now than it was then. The only places I saw that could be considered "lovely" back then were the beach communities on the Narragansett Bay. Warwick, which is close to the water, is not Central Falls. Both were mill towns, however, and most old mill towns were run down 40 years ago because the textile business was moving South and the mills were being abandoned. Some towns have found other ways to survive and some haven't. I have moved around quite a bit, but there's nothing astonishing or even unusual about the way I've lived my life. The best way to experience a place is to live there. Moving from place to place is easy if you live simply and travel light. I had no interest in settling down, so I didn't. It's a family tradition. Meanwhile, I think it's odd and sad that so many people here have a problem with someone who has moved around a lot. It suggests the kind of insularity that rubber is talking about. You've never been able to travel past your own back yards, so you attack anyone who's the least bit curious or adventuresome. I've enjoyed every place I've lived or visited, so I guess that's my revenge. The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize. Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 7/25/2008 Posts: 405 Location: Wauwatosa
|
How did you like the Rhode Island School of Design? How does it compare to MIAD? Nancy wrote:The Troll wrote:Nancy wrote:izzie wrote:I was glad to read the linked article which shed a lot more light on the situation than anything I’d seen previously. Although I initially thought it was a stupid, non-productive, knee-jerk reaction on the part of the board, the pretty good article seems to place a lot of the onus on the teachers’ union not using a little common sense in their negotiations. I would have thought they’d at least be more protective of their jobs.
But, I still think this is show boating on the part of everyone from Duncan on down. Are we supposed to believe the crummiest teachers always end up with the crummiest scores from their students on standardized tests? I suspect none of the sanctioned schools are located in a suburb with demographics similar to, say, Wauwatosa – what a coincidence that we always find the bad teachers in heavily minority schools in high poverty areas. We must make high scores here because of the really good teachers we have, right?
It’s also no surprise to me to discover that Rhode Island is one of the states that has a school choice voucher system. It’s pretty clear that a school like the one in question has been sucked dry of any student who has parents who want to get them out of a pool of troublemakers who nobody gives a darn about except maybe a classroom teacher.
So the solution is to fire the staff? Good luck on the big turnaround when they fill the vacancies with superteachers to fill the vacuum. They can hire teachers back, but no more than 50% so they'll have to fill half the vacancies with new hires. I lived in Providence in the '60s when it was the armpit of America. There have been improvements in the ambiance since then, but I'm guessing that places like Central Falls are still kind of depressed. It's probably an old mill town, just like every place else in Rhode Island. This just just isn't the kind of place that's going to attract lots of bright young things eager to bring new ideas and approaches to educating its children. I'm predicting this will turn out to be a mistake, but we'll see. The Troll is not surprised our well- traveled Nancy has first hand experience with Rhode Island. She is our resident Rhode(s) scholar  Just amazing how she has been everywhere, experienced everything, yet still contributes to our daily lives in such plentitude. The Troll says Warwick, R.I. is not a run down mill town. In fact, Rhode Island is quite lovely. As I said, I lived there forty years ago. That's where I went to art school. I'm aware that it's nicer now than it was then. The only places I saw that could be considered "lovely" back then were the beach communities on the Narragansett Bay. Warwick, which is close to the water, is not Central Falls. Both were mill towns, however, and most old mill towns were run down 40 years ago because the textile business was moving South and the mills were being abandoned. Some towns have found other ways to survive and some haven't. I have moved around quite a bit, but there's nothing astonishing or even unusual about the way I've lived my life. The best way to experience a place is to live there. Moving from place to place is easy if you live simply and travel light. I had no interest in settling down, so I didn't. It's a family tradition. Meanwhile, I think it's odd and sad that so many people here have a problem with someone who has moved around a lot. It suggests the kind of insularity that rubber is talking about. You've never been able to travel past your own back yards, so you attack anyone who's the least bit curious or adventuresome. I've enjoyed every place I've lived or visited, so I guess that's my revenge.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
I went to RISD 40 years ago and I'm sure it has changed quite a bit. I get the alumni bulletin. One obvious change is that the school is much more involved with the surrounding community now than it was then. There seems to be a lot of outreach and collaboration with public schools and social service agencies. I remember RISD being a little island unto itself in the '60s.
The alumni bulletin and the electronic updates that we get periodically focus a lot on the achievements of alumni and my impression is that it's still turning out top notch industrial and graphic designers and illustrators (that was my major). The list of graduates in every field is like a who's who in the arts. Nicole Miller (fashion), Dale Chihuly, and Gus Van Sant were there when I was. So were comedian Martin Mull (an accomplished airbrush artist) and the Talking Heads.
I imagine the curriculum is similar for both schools. My son has a friend who is a freshman at MIAD and we talk about what he's doing there. It sounds familiar. What may make a difference is the caliber of faculty. RISD attracts talented instructors. The proximity to New York makes it easy for people based there to travel in order to teach or even just do master classes. The adjuncts were great. I learned the most from them. A lot of graduates come back to teach. The level of instruction and the competition among students were ferocious, at times.
RISD has some great facilities. There was a foundry on site and access to metal fabricating resources in the community. Chihuly was a graduate student in the late '60s, but he was also developing the glass program. The textile design program has unparalleled resources. We had somewhat limited studio space, but I think they've added a lot so you can pretty much have your own studio now. The museum is also a great resource. You can have museum staff pull items from the collection for research. I was once doing a paper on Paul Poiret, a Belle Epoque era fashion designer who did ladies' evening wear with intricate decorative beading, and they pulled an exquisite Poiret evening coat for me.
I don't know whether that answers your question. I think both places probably offer the most important resource for a developing artist...the opportunity to be in a community of artists and just concentrate on making art for a period of time. Most of my friends have had successful careers as artists. One was a cutting edge fashion photographer before his death. Another has been a successful clothing designer. A couple became painters. Another publishes a highly regarded compilation of design trends for use in fashion, publishing, etc. I think that having the opportunity to experiment and grow and make connections with other artists was critical.
The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize.
Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/10/2007 Posts: 600 Location: Wauwatosa
|
The NYTimes had an article today indicating that President Obama supported the actions of the Rhode Island school board. Needless to say the national school teachers unions expressed their displeasure with his statements.
The article also predicted that this type of school board action would become a more common occurrence in the coming months.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
oldtimer wrote:The NYTimes had an article today indicating that President Obama supported the actions of the Rhode Island school board. Needless to say the national school teachers unions expressed their displeasure with his statements.
The article also predicted that this type of school board action would become a more common occurrence in the coming months. I read that, too. It's interesting. It seems like overkill, to me, but we'll see what happens as the RI case unfolds. The fired teachers will finish out the school year, but I can't imagine that even the most dedicated among them will be able to concentrate on teaching as they face uncertain futures. Some, particularly the ancillary staff like the psychologists and speech therapists, will probably jump ship at the first opportunity. The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize. Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 7/25/2008 Posts: 405 Location: Wauwatosa
|
Thanks Nancy! That was very informative and interesting. I always wondered what that school was like. I also made a career out of the poison we call Art. Nancy wrote:I went to RISD 40 years ago and I'm sure it has changed quite a bit. I get the alumni bulletin. One obvious change is that the school is much more involved with the surrounding community now than it was then. There seems to be a lot of outreach and collaboration with public schools and social service agencies. I remember RISD being a little island unto itself in the '60s.
The alumni bulletin and the electronic updates that we get periodically focus a lot on the achievements of alumni and my impression is that it's still turning out top notch industrial and graphic designers and illustrators (that was my major). The list of graduates in every field is like a who's who in the arts. Nicole Miller (fashion), Dale Chihuly, and Gus Van Sant were there when I was. So were comedian Martin Mull (an accomplished airbrush artist) and the Talking Heads.
I imagine the curriculum is similar for both schools. My son has a friend who is a freshman at MIAD and we talk about what he's doing there. It sounds familiar. What may make a difference is the caliber of faculty. RISD attracts talented instructors. The proximity to New York makes it easy for people based there to travel in order to teach or even just do master classes. The adjuncts were great. I learned the most from them. A lot of graduates come back to teach. The level of instruction and the competition among students were ferocious, at times.
RISD has some great facilities. There was a foundry on site and access to metal fabricating resources in the community. Chihuly was a graduate student in the late '60s, but he was also developing the glass program. The textile design program has unparalleled resources. We had somewhat limited studio space, but I think they've added a lot so you can pretty much have your own studio now. The museum is also a great resource. You can have museum staff pull items from the collection for research. I was once doing a paper on Paul Poiret, a Belle Epoque era fashion designer who did ladies' evening wear with intricate decorative beading, and they pulled an exquisite Poiret evening coat for me.
I don't know whether that answers your question. I think both places probably offer the most important resource for a developing artist...the opportunity to be in a community of artists and just concentrate on making art for a period of time. Most of my friends have had successful careers as artists. One was a cutting edge fashion photographer before his death. Another has been a successful clothing designer. A couple became painters. Another publishes a highly regarded compilation of design trends for use in fashion, publishing, etc. I think that having the opportunity to experiment and grow and make connections with other artists was critical.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 6/11/2007 Posts: 109
|
These crappy school systems keep draining funds from the good ones. The simple act of eliminating tenure might be the first step. Nobody in the private sector gets guarenteed jobs and insurance/retirement packages like public employees. Stop the madness, break a few unions, hold them responsible and have the power to disolve if they are deemed ineffective.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
community spirit wrote:These crappy school systems keep draining funds from the good ones. The simple act of eliminating tenure might be the first step. Nobody in the private sector gets guarenteed jobs and insurance/retirement packages like public employees. Stop the madness, break a few unions, hold them responsible and have the power to disolve if they are deemed ineffective. The only people teaching in public schools who have tenure are college professors. It should be pretty clear from the Central Falls example that school teachers can be fired. The difference between firing someone in the public sector and firing someone in the private sector is that employers in the public sector have to show cause. They have to have a reason and they have to furnish proof. Private sector employees used to have the same kinds of job security, pensions, and benefits that public employees still enjoy. A lot of private sector employees, like healthcare workers, still have decent security, wages and benefits as well. Don't blame public employees because you don't have what they have. Blame your union busting employers for making sure you do more work for less than your parents and grandparents had. The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize. Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/13/2007 Posts: 7,466 Location: East Side Wauwatosa
|
Ted Anthony wrote:Thanks Nancy! That was very informative and interesting. I always wondered what that school was like. I also made a career out of the poison we call Art. Poison? Drug, maybe. I made a career working more with other people's art than with my own, but that has meant that what I do on my own is for me and nobody else unless I want to share it. I've always wondered what my life would have been like if I'd decided to work as an illustrator. I would have had to start out in New York, I think. That's probably less critical now than it used to be. Did you go to MIAD? The difference between humans and other mammals is that we know how to accessorize. Madeleine Albright speaking on the uses of jewelry in diplomacy.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/25/2008 Posts: 36 Location: 'Tosa
|
If you consider travel a form of speech, and in America we do, we are the most talkative people on earth! We change addresses, on average once every five years, more often than any other culture except nomadic tribes. In most countries it's illegal, a poliitical statement bof rebellion against local or national authority. Not here!! You are a great American.
Bust the unions,, give me a break. The Unions are not the problem. Fix the family, fix the problem.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 4/10/2007 Posts: 600 Location: Wauwatosa
|
According to the Milwaukee Journal article this morning, if MPS and the board accept federal funds from the same program, they will have to choose from the same four options for making changes in schools.
|
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 10/26/2007 Posts: 149 Location: Tosa
|
Batman wrote:If you consider travel a form of speech, and in America we do, we are the most talkative people on earth! We change addresses, on average once every five years, more often than any other culture except nomadic tribes. In most countries it's illegal, a poliitical statement bof rebellion against local or national authority. Not here!! You are a great American.
Bust the unions,, give me a break. The Unions are not the problem. Fix the family, fix the problem. Unions are big part of the problem because they end up promoting mediocrity and they protect incompetent teachers. The lengths teacher's unions will go to protect bad teachers would shock most people. Newsweek has a very illuminating article in the March 15 issue about the great difficulty in getting rid of incompetent teachers. In 2008 in New York City, 3 teachers were dismissed for cause, out of 30,000 teachers! That is .01%. The percentage in other districts cited range from 0 to 0.1 percent. Elsewhere in the issue the estimate of the percent of incompetent teachers is about 2%, perhaps much higher in some districts. So, in a district with 500 teachers there may be at least 10 teachers so bad they should be removed from the classroom. Yet, the unions support letting 250-300 students suffer at the hands of these teachers year after year. For even more shocking information, search out the Aug. 31 New Yorker article titled "The Rubber Room." It describes teachers removed from their classrooms for cause who spend years reporting to an empty room (with pay and benefits) while the district fights the legal battle of trying to fire them. Simply amazing. While there are certainly exceptional teachers in many schools, with tenure, automatic raises, and evaluations that have no meaning, mediocre and poor teachers simply have no incentive to improve. Unions are part of the problem because they support, and fight for, continuation of this ridiculous system. In other situations if you harm a child you go to jail. But if you are a teacher who is so bad that you actually reduce the overall achievement of children, and cause them to be less successful in life than they could be, you get union support and automatic raises. Too strong? Maybe. But I find it hard to support a system that defends teachers who actually harm children, and which even fights attempts to improve the evaluation and promotion system.
|
|
|
Guest |
| Forum Jump
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.
|
|